| |

The Storm Cellar, Not Quite a Cinderella Story

A portion of this article appeared in the Carpe Wine column on Vail Daily.

Two sommeliers walk away from the restaurant floor to buy a vineyard and make their own wine. It has all the makings of a fairy tale: a leap of faith, a little farm, a dream finally coming true. But ask Steve Steese and his wife Jayme Henderson of The Storm Cellar how the story has gone, and they’ll tell you it hasn’t exactly been glass slippers and parties.

When we sat down just after the last of the 2026 harvest came in, it was the first day in six weeks, maybe two months, that they hadn’t felt the pressure of harvest. Both admitted they were crashing from the comedown. This was their ninth vintage, and they have been in Colorado’s North Fork Valley for 10 years. “You freak out for a month out of the year,” Jayme told me, “and then you spend the other 11 months trying to figure out how to do it better next year.”

The Storm Cellar took home the two top awards at the 2026 Colorado Governor’s Cup – Best White Wine and Best of Show – for its Reserve Riesling and Best Rosé Wine, in addition to three other gold medals. One of those golds stopped me in my tracks when I was participating as a judge for the competition, the Rosé of Chambourcin. I’m usually not a Chambourcin fan. The hybrid grape is known for searing acidity and a grapefruit-and-red-fruit profile. But as a rosé? Wow.

Steve and Jayme are no strangers to the podium. Their wines have collected medals at the Colorado Governor’s Cup, the Jefferson Cup Invitational, the San Francisco International Wine Competition, the American Fine Wine Competition and the San Francisco Chronicle Wine Competition, to name a few.

Their wins also underline something they hear all the time – “Colorado makes wine?”

Many people are still surprised that Colorado makes wine at all, and even those who know Palisade often don’t realize it’s part of the Grand Valley AVA, the largest wine region in Colorado or that there are other regions, including the West Elk AVA, which is home to The Storm Cellar. The West Elks AVA was also recently named the No. 2 wine region in the U.S., as voted by readers and a panel of experts the publication selects in the USA Today’s 10BEST ranking.

The Storm Cellar, Colorado Winery
Photo Shared from The Storm Cellar, Casey Wilson Photography

Nine Vintages In

Both Jayme and Steve had long careers in the wine industry, including years working at one of the busiest steakhouses in Denver, but neither had ever worked in a winery. They had volunteered and interned, and that small taste of winemaking was enough to convince them they could scale it up. As Steve put it, it took “that amount of crazy faith” to make the jump.

The first handful of years were consumed by the basics: learning the equipment, learning to fix it, learning the process. Now, they say, the equipment, the process and mutual trust in each other are all familiar. They have faced enough broken machinery and bad surprises that quick decisions during the middle of harvest is now based on intuition. Mid-press, one will ask, “Do you think we should do this?” They’ll look at each other and just know the answer.

 

The Storm Cellar, Colorado Winery in the West Elks AVA
Photo Shared from The Storm Cellar, Casey Wilson Photography

When Everything That Could Go Wrong Did – The 2026 Harvest

The 2026 growing season tested that confidence. Farming was the hardest year they’ve had, and it wasn’t only them, every grape grower and vegetable grower they know in Western Colorado had a rough year.

It began with a dry winter, followed by a freak heat wave in March and a crushing freeze in April. Then, right as irrigation season began, a landslide took out the Fire Mountain Canal, the primary irrigation source for the valley, which stayed offline for almost a month. Top it off with the fact they had roughly 4,000 new vines just arrive and were waiting to be planted.

Then there was the freeze. The Storm Cellar delayed pruning to protect its buds, but neighbors who pruned early lost their primary buds, which hurt if not destroyed their yields, and the valley as a whole saw a total loss of tree fruit: no pears, plums, peaches or apples. Tomato blight rounded out the season.

Then came the bears. With their own forage gone, the bears went after the vineyard and ate every berry of the estate chardonnay – 2.5 acres worth. The two spent nights patrolling on ATVs, making noise and leaving radios running. A cub that looked like 50 pounds of cuteness, they said, will bite straight through bird netting and wreck the trellising. It was the second year in a row without chardonnay as last year wasps ate all the berries, and they had just spent heavily on fine-mesh netting to stop them. The fix for next year is a pair of Great Pyrenees mixed dogs, adopted from a shelter in Grand Junction, who will become permanent vineyard patrol.

Because The Storm Cellar also buys fruit from other Colorado vineyards, every grower they work with came in short on every variety. To say 2026 was a hard year is an understatement.  

The Storm Cellar, Colorado Winery in West Elks AVA
Photo Shared from The Storm Cellar, Casey Wilson Photography

Loss and Rebuilding

The vineyard has taught them harder lessons, too. Phylloxera, the root louse that most people think of as a problem for another century, is here. All of Colorado was originally planted ungrafted, leaving vines wide open to it, and plenty of growers still plant ungrafted vinifera on the theory that the state’s extreme climate would keep the pest away. “Once it’s here, it’s here to stay,” Steve said.

As first-time farmers, they spent years and a lot of money nursing vines that should have been pulled. Eventually they started ripping out acres and replanting on grafted rootstock. Roughly a dozen acres have gone in and are just beginning to come online. They see an upside: a blank slate to improve the soil, the trellis system and the water delivery, and to add regenerative practices, including animals (babydoll sheep for mowing and rotational grazing, plus eggs and meat for the tasting room).

It isn’t easy. “You have to deal with death and the loss,” Jayme said, “but then it makes you excited about what you’re doing in the future.” There’s reward in it, they added, when good things come out, and it is, frankly, the two of them dealing with all of it.

Colorado Wine Regions - The West Elks AVA, The Storm Cellar
Photo Shared from The Storm Cellar, Casey Wilson Photography

Forget the Red, It’s All Whites & Rosés

The Storm Cellar is strictly focused on producing white and rosé wines, rather than adhering to the outdated notion that red wine is the sole profit driver. The couple invested in equipment and expertise built specifically for white wine and rosé, and, in their words, “we’re trying to make the kinds of wines that we want to drink.”

Altitude helps the case. At about 6,000 feet, grapes tend toward thick skins and high acidity, which can mean bright acidity that shines in whites and rosés. After crush, they cold soak the juice on those thick grape skins to build complexity before pressing and fermenting in stainless steel, and they gently stir the lees on some varieties to add texture. The result is wines with bright acid and complex layers. You can see this in their award-winning sparkling Riesling, Cloudburst, which is made using the traditional Champagne method. It’s one of the wines Jayme said they are most excited about and see as a key indicator of the direction of Colorado winemaking given the state’s high-acid growing conditions.

Their Rosé of Chambourcin shows how they think as winemakers. Chambourcin is a hybrid with very high acidity and a grapefruit and red fruit profile. Many people meet it off-dry – sweeter wine – because that’s the only way to balance the acid, or as a dry red where the acid is overwhelming. The Storm Cellar sources their Chambourcin fruit from the Grand Valley, it is difficult to ripen reliably in the West Elks region due to potential early fall frosts. They wanted a rosé with enough richness for a summer barbecue but can still be sipped on in the dead of winter.

As Steve put it, “If I’m grilling a steak and it’s 95 degrees outside I want a lighter wine that can still stand up to it. It also works with smoked pork tenderloin, tacos, fall stews and makes for a perfect Thanksgiving wine since it holds up to so many different dishes.”

Colorado Wine - West Elks AVA, The Storm Cellar
Photo Shared from The Storm Cellar, Casey Wilson Photography

The Goal Is Simple: Come Visit

Steve and Jayme are blunt about one of their goals – come visit West Elks. “That’s the goal of this valley: come visit.” This year, The West Elks AVA was named the No. 2 wine region in the U.S., as voted by readers and a panel of experts the publication selects in the USA Today’s 10BEST ranking.

A four-hour drive across the Rockies ends in wine country, they point out, and you don’t have to plan a trip anywhere else. The West Elks AVA – which includes the towns of Hotchkiss, Paonia and Crawford – has roughly 12 to 14 wineries and cideries on its trail, in a valley with no traffic lights, no fast food and no chains, just small independent farms of four to 10 acres.

With Steve and Jayme’s help, I’ve put together a short itinerary for your next grape escape to Colorado Wine Country. Cheers!